Acreage alone tells you less than you'd think about a Cottontown parcel. Under Sumner County's current zoning, much of the land around Cottontown carries a minimum lot size of about 2.3 acres. That minimum rises to 5 acres when the property lacks adequate public water, sits more than 500 feet from a fire hydrant, or fronts a county or state road with less than 18 feet of pavement or fewer than two connections to a public road. Take two 10-acre tracts that look identical on a listing. If one has water, a hydrant and a wide road, it could hold roughly twice as many homesites on paper as the other.
That's the first thing I check when a client wants to buy land and build. Most of Cottontown is unincorporated, so the rules come from the county, not a city. Recent county agendas show new home sites here coming as small splits on land zoned Rural Preservation. One example is a proposed two-lot split of 5.03 acres on Watt Nolen Road. Another is a 4.24-acre family subdivision on Circle Drive. Those small splits are the way new homesites get created here, and the infrastructure rules decide how many each parcel can produce.
The Three Conditions That Turn a Lot Into Five Acres
The Sumner County Zoning Resolution, with revisions effective December 8, 2025, sets base minimums for the rural districts. Rural Preservation, or RP, starts at 100,000 square feet. Rural Residential, or RR, starts at 40,000 square feet. Agricultural Reserve requires 15 acres. In RP and RR, those base minimums only apply when the infrastructure is in place. Here is the resolution's language on hydrants:
"Lots not located within 500 feet of a fire hydrant may not be less than 5 acres, or 217,800 square feet."
The same section applies the 5-acre floor in two other cases. One is when the water provider says service is unavailable or doesn't meet its minimums. The other is when the road out front has under 18 feet of pavement or doesn't connect to the public road network in at least two places. An owner who doesn't meet those conditions has two choices under the resolution. They can partition by deed into lots of at least 5 acres, or they can install the missing infrastructure so the standard district minimum applies.
That second choice matters most to someone weighing land as an investment in future lots. A hydrant or a water line is something you can build and pay for. The tract's value to a future buyer can depend on whether that work is possible and what it costs.
Two Lots and Three Lots Face Different Tests
The resolution gives a partial exemption to minor subdivisions. A minor subdivision is exempt from the hydrant and road conditions as long as public water is available and the lot meets the district's normal minimum. The county's 2026 Subdivision Regulations, effective April 21, 2026, define a minor subdivision as fewer than three lots. A plat moves to major review if it has three or more lots, new or extended streets, public improvements, drainage work, or a requested waiver.
In practice, a two-lot split in RP or RR that stays a minor subdivision faces only one infrastructure test, public water. A third lot, a new or extended street, drainage work or a waiver request makes it a major subdivision, and then the hydrant and road tests apply too. Major review also means a preliminary plat and construction documents before the final plat. Minor review is typically staff review of a final plat. The county's minor-plat checklist says staff may approve plats of two lots or fewer when county requirements are met and no variance is requested. If a seller describes land as "easy to split," you can test that claim by checking whether the plan still qualifies as a minor subdivision.
Frontage is a separate issue. The zoning table's lot width at the building line is a different measurement from street frontage. Subdivision lots generally have to touch a public street continuously for at least 50 feet, with some exceptions, including tracts of 5 acres or more.
The County Set Out to Make Rural Splits Harder
These rules are on purpose. A February 2024 Planning Commission staff report describes eight public study sessions on lot sizes during 2023. It also notes that 40,000-square-foot lots had been allowed across most of the unincorporated county since zoning began in 1973. The report quotes the county's 2035 Comprehensive Plan, adopted in 2010, which said that approach "does not consider topographic constraints and encourages a sprawling development pattern without incentivizing concentrated development."
Staff proposed the RP district with a 5-acre default. Smaller lots would be allowed where water, fire-flow and road infrastructure could support them. The Planning Commission recommended the package on May 21, 2024, and the county's planning page lists the zoning map as adopted July 29, 2024. If you're comparing a Cottontown tract with land you looked at a few years ago, the earlier rules may have allowed more lots. The June 2023 version of the resolution had the 5-acre water condition but no hydrant or road conditions.
Family Lots Skip the Rule but Stay in the Family
There is one route around the 5-acre floor, and it carries a restriction that affects anyone buying from outside the family. Family subdivisions are fully exempt from the infrastructure conditions. They allow lots as small as 40,000 square feet, about 0.92 acres, for sale or gift to immediate family. The resolution defines immediate family as a child, stepchild, spouse, sibling, grandchild, grandparent, parent or stepparent. The number of extra lots depends on the size of the parent parcel:
| Parent parcel size | Additional family lots allowed |
|---|---|
| 1.84 to 2.75 acres | 1 |
| 2.76 to 5.0 acres | 2 |
| 5 to 9.99 acres | 3 |
| 10 to 14.99 acres | 4 |
| 15 to 24.99 acres | 5 |
| 25 to 49.99 acres | 6 |
| 50 acres and greater | 7 |
The table above matches the resolution's wording, and the resolution puts exactly 5.0 acres in two brackets. If your parcel sits right at 5 acres, ask county planning staff which allowance applies.
Family lots must also be 100 feet wide on minor roads, 150 feet on collector roads and 200 feet on arterial roads. Setbacks are 40 feet in front, 20 feet on the sides and 30 feet in the rear. Every lot still has to meet state septic rules.
The restriction is in item g. Every family-subdivision lot needs a restrictive covenant that bars transfer to anyone outside the immediate family for 15 years after the split. The exceptions are involuntary transfers such as foreclosure, death, judicial sale, condemnation or bankruptcy. The plat must be labeled "Family Subdivision," and both the owner and the family member receiving the lot sign a county affidavit. So before a relocating buyer gets attached to a small Cottontown lot, I look up the recorded plat. If it says "Family Subdivision," the date of the split matters as much as the price.
The Soil Also Has a Say
Public water may be available in parts of Cottontown, but sewer often isn't, and septic sets its own limit. The county requires each lot to have enough onsite area for an approved septic system. Lots can't rely on a neighbor's easement unless an exception is approved. The minor-plat checklist asks for a high-intensity soils map stamped by a Tennessee-licensed soil scientist.
At the state level, the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation requires a subdivision evaluation when land is divided into two or more lots for building on septic. Divisions where every resulting tract is at least 5 acres are excluded. TDEC's septic FAQ says an environmental scientist evaluates the site to decide what type of system it can support. Complete applications can take up to 45 days. TDEC's construction permit fees are $400 for a new conventional system up to 1,000 gallons per day, with a $100 inspection. An alternative system costs $500, with a $200 inspection. A soil result that calls for an alternative system affects more than the permit fee. It also changes where the house, the drive and the field lines can go.
What Water Costs Once You Know Who Provides It
Water decides whether a two-lot split is possible at all, so the first call is to the provider. More than one utility serves this part of Sumner County. White House Utility District has an address lookup on its service area page.
- WHUD: A 5/8 x 3/4-inch tap is $2,000 and a 1-inch tap is $2,800, each plus a $50 new-account fee. These charges don't apply to subdivision main extensions, and the customer pays for the line from the tap to the house, according to WHUD's posted fees.
- Castalian Springs–Bethpage: Taps are $3,000 for 3/4-inch, $4,000 for 1-inch and $4,500 for 2-inch. There is a $50 owner application fee and a $2,000 capacity fee for developments of three or more lots, per its charges and fees schedule. Its developer policy says a letter of availability is valid for 120 days and doesn't guarantee service if capacity or pressure falls short. Developers pay for on-site and off-site improvements, and the as-built records include water mains and fire hydrants.
Neither schedule lists a price for a new hydrant or main extension. If an infrastructure fix is the only way to get under 5 acres, that cost is an engineering estimate. A posted fee won't cover it.
Five Things to Check Before You Write an Offer on Land
- Confirm the zoning district on the county map. RP, RR and Agricultural Reserve start from very different minimums.
- Get the water provider's answer in writing, and note how long any availability letter is valid.
- Measure the distance to the nearest hydrant and the pavement width of the road, and count the road's public connections.
- Pull the recorded plat and look for a "Family Subdivision" label and its date.
- Plan time and money for a soils map and a TDEC evaluation before you count lots.
On the county side, the fee schedule effective September 21, 2026 lists a $500 special-exception application, which is the step that comes before a family plat. It also lists a $250 minor-plat fee and $200 per lot for residential plan review. This post is general information and isn't legal, tax or engineering advice. Confirm your own parcel with Sumner County planning staff, TDEC, your water provider and an attorney.
The Rules Are Up for Review Again
On October 15, 2026, Sumner County released a request for qualifications for a consultant to update the 2035 Comprehensive Plan. Proposals are due November 17, 2026, and the county estimates the work will be finished in January 2028 or sooner. The scope includes reviewing land use, zoning and growth since the last update, along with public meetings. It doesn't prescribe new lot sizes. The county has been working toward this since at least early 2025. Main Street Media reported that a public survey ran from January 17 to March 14 that year. The 2024 lot-size rules came out of the current plan, so anyone holding land for a future split should follow the update's public meetings.
Quick Answers
Can I split 5 acres in RP into two lots? Two lots of 2.5 acres each are above RP's 100,000-square-foot minimum. If the split qualifies as a minor subdivision, it skips the hydrant and road tests only if public water is available. Without public water, each lot has to be at least 5 acres. Septic soils still have to work on each lot.
Does the 5-acre rule apply to a lot that already exists? The 2024 package included provisions for nonconforming RR and RP lots. Ask county planning staff how a specific older lot is treated.
Can an outside buyer purchase a family-subdivision lot? Not during the 15-year covenant period, except through the involuntary transfers listed in the resolution.
If you're considering a Cottontown tract and want someone to work through the water letter, the hydrant distance and the soils report with you before you commit, Jacqueline Brown can help you collect those documents and line up the county staff, utility, soil scientist and attorney who give the final answers. Book a Call, and bring the parcel address.